HONORS
On January 6, 1814, both Perry and Elliott received Congressional Gold Medals and the Thanks of Congress. This was in recognition of the first-time ever capture of an entire British squadron at the Battle of Lake Erie. In addition, each man received an equal portion of the prize money ($7,140 apiece)
In recognition of Perry's position as commodore of the squadron, Congress gave him an extra $5,000. This became a bone of contention with Elliott.
CONTROVERSY
Even before the medals were awarded, Elliott and Perry became embroiled in a 30-year battle over their respective conduct and fault in the battle. This extended even beyond Perry's death in 1819. Perry claimed that Elliott had failed to offer timely support; Elliott decried there was a lack of communication and signals on Perry's part.
In 1818, Perry drew up a list of charges against Elliott, but was evidently dissuaded by the Secretary of the Navy against formally filing them.
And it still wasn't over, even in death.
--Brock-Perry
